Unfortunately, in this broken world we live in, trust is often compromised. Spouses betray each other, politicians lie, public figures disappoint.
As leaders, we may find ourselves in a place where trust has been compromised. Perhaps we’ve disappointed others by our behavior or words. What can we do to restore trust when trust is broken?
Before we get to that, let’s explore what it means to trust. There are two dimensions of trust – character and competence.
Character speaks to the attributes, values and motivations of the person or institution. It raises questions like the following -
“Is the leader humble?”
“Is she kind?”
“Is he a man of integrity?”
“Does the institution pursue truth?
It surprises some to hear this but character alone is not enough to secure trust. You also have to be competent. When you trust someone, you are confident, not simply in their intentions and motivations toward you, but also in their advice and their ability to help you. For example – when you invest trust in your car mechanic, you’re counting on his character - that he will not cheat you by billing you excessively – and on his competence – that he will be able to fix the problem at hand.
So back to our question – what can you do to restore trust when trust is lost? Here are 4 things to consider: (Disclaimer: nothing original here – it’s a combination of things I’ve learned from reading, observing and painfully experiencing)
Talk straight – speak honestly and openly. No spinning the message, no sweeping under the rug. Invite others to do the same. Trust cannot be restored when we’re afraid of expressing ourselves to each other. A leader can facilitate straight talk is by being vulnerable. Lead the way by letting your guard down. This is step one in the road to restoring trust.
Confront the brutal truth - acknowledging the truth about a situation is essential to fixing the fundamental problem of mistrust. That’s why a common complaint about politicians that have lost the trust of the public is that they “just don’t get it”. One way to face the truth is to let those you’ve wronged to openly give you feedback without retribution or correction. I’ve been in situations where I’ve lost the trust of individuals even though I haven’t explicitly wronged them. Yet, in both humility and care for others, I needed to put aside the temptation to defend myself but focus instead on how they have been affected by my leadership.
Make It Right (as best you can) - Making it right starts with bearing the burdens of others. Understanding how our leadership (or lack thereof) has affected them. Sometimes when trust is lost, it’s due to an irreversible situation but if possible, you need to make amends and offer reparations. It also means proactive mitigation - making the kind of changes that prevent the same situation from occurring again. Regaining trust requires us answering the question – “what assurances can you offer me that this won’t happen again?“.
Follow Through - Actions speak louder than words. Those whom you may have wronged - your constituents, followers and friends are looking for results. Placating them but not following through with actual results will compromise everything else. It will further disillusion them. This means both fulfilling commitments made to them and continuing to be accountable to them. Here’s what I mean - it’s not enough to simply address the problem in the current moment but to continue to humbly inquire if you’re on the right track. Leaders that restore trust willingly make themselves accountable to those they lead on an ongoing basis.
Final word on this - I've seen good leaders demonstrate this in many different settings and I've tried to practice the same. I don't know they do it but for me, the impetus and strength to do so is rooted firmly in gospel truth.
Speaking openly and honestly comes from knowing that there is such a thing as objective truth and that it proceeds from a God of truth for our good. ( Psalm 119:160 , John 17:17 )
Confronting the truth in any situation is easier once you've confronted the cosmic truth that you're a sinner before a holy God. ( Romans 3:23 ).
Having the strength to act humbly and courageously emanates from the gospel - that God humbled himself by sending his Son in human form to bear our sins. ( Philippians 2: 5-8 )
We become motivated to bear the burdens of others when we consider the burden Christ bore for us on the cross and walk in love toward them. ( Galatians 6:2 )
5 comments:
Good points, ESI.
humility, change, confession of sin, God's grace, reconciliation, (arms open and waiting until embrace as in reconciliation comes- Volf, "Exclusion and Embrace--sadly Volf recently went through divorce, but still active, don't know what happened), hard down-to-earth practice. commitment to that.
in weaknesses is strength, and this is part of that path of weakness in Christ. well, this is from my perspective.
one more thing: this is in context of following Christ. I really don't believe in grace anymore, or I struggle with reference to it. we don't practice what Jesus taught us, and we don't believe in grace. Very sad. We're to forgive immediately and be reconciled as those in Christ's Body.
Our only hope is in the Lord, but it is a hope for here and now, to be worked out in community. But church too often seems too broken.
Just my meandering thoughts. I should go to the poetry time with L.L.Barkat and friends and work out a poem along these lines, I suppose.
...let me add just this: true leadership takes the place of a humble servant, even lowly slave. Over and over true leaders will confess their sins when they need to.
And this: we are all in this together. Leaders model what everyone is to practice. Leaders should be held to the higher standard only to lead, but really everyone in Jesus is required, or called in grace to do these things, painful though they are.
To acknowledge if one's a jerk, or really was unfair in something they said. Etc.
Good post ESI! Much said and well done! :)
On second thought, our church, Redeemer Covenant Church is a body in which grace prevails among us. In spite of some of us being polar opposites on divisive issues politically, and even theologically (ref: my Christian pacifism, which actually our denomination has traditionally had those who were such). No place perfect, of course, but through sacrament and obedience to Christ's commands, I believe grace prevails among us, for which I am so thankful.
not place, but church. local churches in places, of course.
Post a Comment